Go to The French Paradox Resolved Go to List of Paris Bistros Go to The Democratization of Excellence Go to Whitings writings Home Page John Talbott: Le Gaigne in the 8th: Not like the old place in many ways.

“- prices many times that at the old haunt .”

So read this as ancient history:


Made it, Ma! Top of the World!

Le Gaigne





It says a great deal about the state of the economy that Le Gaigne’s opening last year generated something like the excitement of L’Astrance eight years before. There was a big difference between the two in the level of architectural sophistication – if a few decorative features were stripped out of this new little 20-seater, it could pass for a neighbourhood café. And unlike L'Astrance, it’s a totally informal mom-and-pop operation, the chef’s young wife cordially and efficiently serving front-of-house in faded jeans. Only the elegant wood-bound carte and, subsequently, the even more elegantly plated dishes, give the game away.


Due perhaps to Mark Bitman’s enthusiasm in the New York Times, the predominant voices in the room were upper-class American. In one corner was a table of six Golden Oldies, archetypal representatives of the Ivy League/St. Grottlesex brigade. At the end of the evening they left in a stretch taxi.


Like the other rising young stars in the Paris bistro scene, Mickael Gaignon served his apprenticeship in some very up-market establishments (Le Pre Catelan, Pierre Gaignaire and, most recently, Gaya). Following the critical consensus, we decided to sample his versatility with the menu degustation. Mary is a light drinker, so I opted for a single serving of the wine flight. (She got most of the Muscat, which she's rather fond of.)

Menu dégustation cinq plats seul 39€

Le Menu accompagné des 3 verres suivants 54€

Les Légumes d'Eté

Terrine d'aubergine, courgette et poivron, bâtonnets de concombres au yaourt de brebis, sauce poivron

Summer vegetables: Terrine of aubergine, courgette and sweet pepper
[basically, a cold ratatouille]; cucumber sticks in sheep’s yoghurt; pepper sauce.



Le Bulot

      A l'aïloli, dans sa corne d'abondance,
tartine de radis et copeaux de légumes croquants

Whelks in aioli, served in a cornucopia [inedible];
toast with radishes; shavings of crunchy vegetables


La lotte de Manche

Queue rôtie sur unr tranche de ventrèche
de porc Ibaiona, coco plat

Monkfish  tail roasted on a slice of grilled pork belly; haricot beans

Le Poulet Fermier de Challans

Suprême cuit en blanquette, cuisse en caillette
à la noisette, champignons farcis et roquette

Farm chicken two ways: breast stewed in creamy stock;
thigh meat stuffed in a faggot with hazelnuts; stuffed mushrooms; rocket



Poché à la vanille, panacotta. Chantilly et
guimauve au parfum de Tilleul

Apricot poached with vanilla; Chantilly panacotta;
marshmallow cubes perfumed with lime



It was all quite stunning and kept bringing to mind our introduction to L'Astrance years before. If I lived in Paris, I'd be back often by no means an extravagance at lunch time, when the Formule déjeuner is only 16€ or 22€.


Back in 2001, Bénédict Beaugé began a column, "The most important gastronomic event of the last few months in Paris has been, to my mind, the opening of L'Astrance. . . . I hope that L'Astrance will be a model for a new type of gastronomique establishment - both less expensive and much less formal than we've had in France before at this level." Since then, while L’Astrance has ascended into the stratosphere, the economic goal posts for its successors have been lowered practically to ground level. During this evening’s tour de force, we were continually impressed both with the level of expertise and the economy of ingredients. Indeed, the only animal protein was a small quantity of whelk (the cheapest of shellfish – at La Ferrandaise, we’d been given a whole bowl as an amuse bouche) and a few ounces of monkfish, pork belly and chicken.

In the loo after dinner I found the perfect metaphor of Pere et Mere Gaignon’s brilliant little operation. The washbasin had been wittily improvised from a galvanized bucket, but there was a basket of soft hand towels. All rather rococo, like the classy nymphs and shepherds in a Watteau landscape. How long will it be before Le Gaigne moves up market? That may well depend on the market itself.

Le Gaigne 12 rue Pecquay, 4th, Tel: 01 44 59 86 72, Mº Hotel de Ville

©2009 John Whiting

  • Back to the beginning of this review